Skip to Main Content

A Call to Action - Be Better Thinkers!

19 November 2026

It is easy at times to slip into using and validating the quick soundbites we read on social media. I was reflecting on this recently with a LinkedIn post that popped into my feed. The post was about funding for independent schools in Australia. 

The post was a call to action - “Governments should stop funding private education in Australia!” 

On face value it is strong call to action and a valid opinion to have; however, the underlying premise is not entirely accurate. Regardless, when the post is liked and reposted, this premise goes unchallenged and a factual inaccuracy is perpetuated. To put it crudely, the lie becomes the truth and flies through the social media ether. As a result, discussions around government funding become polarised into a zero-sum game where you are either for or against government funding for independent schools. There is no space between or nuance to the argument. 

One of the reasons such a call-to-action gains traction across social media and in people’s consciousness, is because the argument it advocates is simple and therefore easily replicated. The actual way in which government funding in education works is much more complicated, and it takes time, slower thinking and dialogue to really understand. Even as a Principal I find the funding model challenging to explain, but I am going to give it a try! 

The flaw in the LinkedIn post I referenced above, and much of the commentary in the media about school funding, is that funding is not for schools per say but for the students in our schools. 

At HVGS we get funding that is commiserate with the number of students we have, their needs and our parents’ capacity to pay for schooling expenses (this capacity is determined by the government). This is how it works:  

  • The government provides a base amount of funding for each student in a school, across all sectors (public, independent, catholic etc.). This base amount is considered the per student starting amount for primary and secondary education. Schools receive funding based on the number of students in their schools.  
  • In independent schools, the amount of money received for each student is adjusted based on the taxable income of families. This generates a Capacity to Contribute (CTC) score for HVGS. This score then determines how much money a school receives per student. The higher the score, the less money a school receives as the Government assessment indicates that parents are able to pay more towards the costs of schooling. (Every year we are required to submit information about our families so that our CTC score can be determined.)  
  • This means that public spending on education is needs based and therefore can be seen as equitable. HVGS receives funding based the students we have in our classrooms and our parents collective CTC.  
  • Schools also receive loadings and this is based on the needs of the student body. For example, HVGS receives additional funding (in terms of loadings) for students with diagnosed disabilities. The amount we receive is proportionate to the needs of students. 

Explaining government funding for education took far more space than a quick soundbite on social media allows. And it also requires more cognitive effort for myself and everyone reading this blogpost! 

In schools we should cultivate the ability of students to engage in cognitive effort. We want them to work hard as thinkers. The example of school funding I use above, and how it might be discussed and represented across media, is an example of reductive thinking. The complexity that sits behind the idea is reduced to something simple, digestible and easily replicable in social media. It also produces a self-replicating narrative that strays further and further away from the reality of the model itself. 

In a similar way, the public discourse about technology, screen time and AI is reductive. Edicts about banning technology or placing time limits (down to the minute) on acceptable usage in public schools are a band aid that does little to address a fundamental concern. We want our children to live balanced lives, be able to think deeply and slowly, and engage in sustained reading. We want them outside playing as well as feeling connected to their peers. We want them accessing and using technology at the right time, and not too early.  

The public conversation, and policy debate about technology advocates for a one-size fits all approach and misses the nuance. I feel for public sector colleagues who now have an additional compliance burden - monitoring and reporting on the number of minutes students are spending on their devices at school each day. A more nuanced approach might sound like this: 

“Small, consistent changes tend to work better than rigid rules that are hard to sustain. Technology itself is neither inherently good nor bad. 

The most useful goal is intentional use: choosing content and contexts that support development while protecting the everyday experiences - rest, movement, real-world connection, and unstructured play - that help young brains thrive.” 

(Source: Family Screen Time Toolkit: Age Limits and 5 Pillars | BHI) 

 

The Rutgers Brain Health Institute provides an evidence-based and moderated approach to parenting in the age of screens. I love these five simple tips for parents (it truly is this simple without being a one-size fits all approach): 

 

Create one consistent device-free pocket (family dinners are a realistic, high-impact starting point). 

Prioritize sleep and outdoor or active time - these often deliver the largest returns. 

Favour shared or co-viewed screen time over long stretches of solo scrolling, especially with younger children. 

Pay more attention to what screens are replacing (talk, play, movement) than to exact minute counts. 

Model the habits you want - children notice adult phone use. Reducing parental smartphone time during interactions can support language and attachment. 

 

(Source: Screen Time and Child Development: What Research Says | BHI) 

 

This has not been a short blogpost and there is a reason for this. I have broached two thorny issues - school funding and technology - that are often oversimplified by the media and on social media. Both are complex issues that are reduced to a binary argument that encourages polarised thinking where one approach is right and the other is wrong.

Nuance matters. Context matters and just as humans are not simple neither are the ideas, solutions and polices we create. Social media soundbites rarely help us embrace complexity and ambiguity. By contrast, our children need to be adaptable and resilient human beings who can navigate complexity, ambiguity and change.  

If we want our children to be in “Explorer Mode”, to draw on Anderson and Withrop’s notion of The Disengaged Teen, then we need to be vigilant in modelling open-mindedness and curiosity. Explorers are engaged at all levels - behaviourally, emotionally and cognitively. They are not easy students to be around as they are deeply curious, keen to question everything, and hungry to learn and put their learning into action. They are ready for the world as it emerges and changes around them. 

To return to the LinkedIn post above, which provided a great opportunity for me to demystify government funding for schools, it is great that we can like and repost calls to action that we are passionate about. With this also comes a responsibility to be curious and open to engaging with ideas in all their complexity and thorniness. We need to pause before we post and repost to ask ourselves the questions we want to hear from our learners: 

  • How do you know that? 
  • What evidence might you be drawing on to make that conclusion? 
  • What other ideas or perspectives might you need to take into consideration? 
  • And, do I have all the information I need to have an opinion about this, or am I oversimplifying something that is really important to others?  
  • Might I be perpetuating misunderstanding rather than understanding? 

I argue that as adults we need to be better thinkers. When we are, our children will be and the world desperately needs critical, compassionate and curious thinkers who are unwilling to settle for the quick soundbite that travels far on social media. 

Works cited 

Anderson, Jenny, and Rebecca Winthrop. The Disengaged Teen: Helping Kids Learn Better, Feel Better, and Live Better. Vermilion, 2025. 

Screen Time and Child Development: What Research Says | BHI